In Response to a 2024 DOJ Report, Phoenix Police Claim They Won't Use Force Excessively on Kids. Yet, All Force Used Offensively on People is Excessive, Authority to do so is Immoral and Illegitimate
/From [HERE] In June 2024, the Department of Justice issued a damning report on the abuses of Phoenix police, laying out in painstaking detail how cops routinely trampled the rights of residents. Some of those abuses involved minors, who were on the receiving end of unnecessary force and aggressive treatment by police.
“(The Phoenix Police Department) does not take into account the vulnerability of children and their stage of development,” the DOJ report read. “As one sergeant explained, ‘We don’t really treat youth any differently than adults.’”
Now, in an announcement that reads like a direct response to the DOJ report, the police department has avowed it will treat youth differently from adults. On Thursday, Phoenix police publicized its new “Youth Interactions” policies, which are meant to guide officers in their encounters with minors.
The department is seeking public input on the new policies, which are not merely updates to previous policies. Phoenix police spokesperson Sgt. Jennifer Zak confirmed to Phoenix New Times that the department “did not previously have a policy specifically for the interactions with our youth, who are an important part of our community.”
“This new policy is all part of the Phoenix Police Department’s commitment to continuous improvement,” she added.
The city is accepting comments on the policy through Nov. 22.
The new policies begin with an assertion that should seem obvious: that “youth are developmentally different from adults” and that police should calibrate their interactions according to those differences. From there, the policies go on to provide guidelines on practices that were specifically called out in the DOJ report.
Answering the DOJ report
One portion of the new policies discusses when and why cops can place handcuffs on minors. The DOJ report noted that Phoenix officers “use excessive force during encounters with kids,” and that “nearly every child we interviewed complained officers closed handcuffs on their wrists so tightly that they reached the point of pain and injury.” In some cases, the cuffs were so tight that kids’ hands went numb and their wrists carried marks for months.
“Others said they sustained deep cuts on their wrists and, when they asked officers to loosen the cuffs, PhxPD instead tightened them further,” the report said.
Seemingly in response, the new youth interaction policies state that “the Department recognizes that detaining or handcuffing youth may cause trauma.” The policies now prohibit cops from handcuffing kids “to intimidate or scare them” or when kids “are not under arrest or detained and/or do not pose a safety risk.” If kids are found to have committed no offense, they are to be uncuffed “immediately.” [MORE]
